No. 26-SYRP-112 · Court of Breakfast Claims, Kitchen Table Division
Maple v. The Pancake Breakfast
A dog named Maple is denied every pancake breakfast. Her humans say she was named after a tree, and that she already gets the eggs the baby drops.
Pending
Statement of Facts
- ¶ 1Plaintiff, Maple, says she was named after her humans’ favorite pancake topping.
- ¶ 2Every Sunday, the humans make a tall stack of pancakes. Plaintiff is given nothing (Exhibit N).
- ¶ 3Plaintiff has sat politely under the table for an average of forty-five minutes per breakfast, with no results.
Arguments Presented
- ¶ 1Counsel argued that naming a dog after a breakfast item creates a reasonable expectation of breakfast.
- ¶ 2The defense answered that Maple was named after the maple tree, not the syrup. Trees, they noted, do not eat pancakes.
- ¶ 3The defense then said that the only "maple syrup" in the house is Plaintiff’s own drool, which pools under the table every Sunday.
- ¶ 4Finally, the defense showed that Plaintiff already gets the scrambled eggs the baby drops from the high chair. Counsel objected that this is "a different meal entirely."
Holding
No ruling yet. The court finds the tree defense surprisingly strong and the drool evidence hard to deny. The court also notes that Plaintiff already has a breakfast arrangement with the baby, and asks both sides to settle over a plain pancake.
“She is named after a tree. The syrup is her drool. And she gets the baby’s eggs.”