Wu, Woof & AssociatesFree Consultation
← All Case Files

No. 26-CONE-360 · Court of Medical Indignities

Lucy v. The Cone of Shame

After a minor procedure, the Plaintiff is forced to wear a plastic lampshade on her head. She brings suit for loss of dignity and peripheral vision.

Closed

Statement of Facts

  1. ¶ 1Plaintiff, Lucy, was fitted with the Defendant after a routine vet visit.
  2. ¶ 2Since then, Plaintiff has walked into three doorframes, one coffee table, and the back of the couch (Exhibit O).
  3. ¶ 3Plaintiff can no longer reach her water bowl without knocking it over.

Arguments Presented

  1. ¶ 1Counsel argued that the Defendant is a satellite dish, not a medical device.
  2. ¶ 2Counsel noted the scuff marks on every doorframe in the house.
  3. ¶ 3The vet argued the Cone is "for her own good." Plaintiff responded by backing slowly into the vet.

Holding

Settled out of court. The Cone will be replaced with a soft donut collar. Plaintiff will also be allowed to lie on the good couch until she heals.

“My client is not a lamp, Your Honor.”
— Mia Filsinger, oral argument

Have a similar case?

Sit. Stay. Consult.