Wu, Woof & AssociatesFree Consultation
← All Case Files

No. 26-HUSH-404 · Court of Quiet Enjoyment, Living Room Division

Wu, Woof & Associates v. Pawrents

In re False Noise Violations. Two upstanding members of the bar are wrongly accused of being loud, and set the record straight.

Case Won

Statement of Facts

  1. ¶ 1The Pawrents have issued Juno and Mia a number of noise citations, including "barking at nothing," "whining at the door," "zoomies after 10 PM," "stomping loudly on the hardwood floors," and "shaking the whole bed by jumping on it."
  2. ¶ 2Counsel denies all of it. There is always something. The Pawrents simply cannot hear it.
  3. ¶ 3The Pawrents placed a decibel meter on the windowsill to gather evidence. The only loud object found at the scene was a rubber chicken, which does not belong to either client (Exhibit M).

Arguments Presented

  1. ¶ 1Counsel argued that barking at "nothing" is in fact barking at a leaf, a noise three houses away, or a very suspicious shadow.
  2. ¶ 2Counsel argued that whining at the door is not noise, but a clear and polite request to go outside.
  3. ¶ 3Counsel argued that the loud footsteps are not stomping. Nails on hardwood simply carry, and the Pawrents chose the floors.
  4. ¶ 4Counsel argued that a bed cannot be "shaken" by a graceful landing, and that any wobbling is a problem with the mattress, not the jumper.
  5. ¶ 5Counsel pointed out that the Pawrents themselves regularly play loud music, run the blender at 7 AM, and sing in the shower. No citations were issued.
  6. ¶ 6Halfway through closing arguments, the doorbell rang. Both counsel barked for four straight minutes. The Court agreed to strike this from the record.

Holding

For the Plaintiffs. The citations are thrown out for lack of evidence, and the rubber chicken has been taken into custody. The Court finds that the dogs were not loud; they were simply keeping everyone informed.

“My clients do not make noise. They make announcements.”
— Mia Filsinger, closing argument

Have a similar case?

Sit. Stay. Consult.