Wu, Woof & AssociatesFree Consultation
← All Case Files

No. 22-SQK-042 · Small Claims Court of the Living Room Rug

Mia v. The Stuffed Duck

The pro se victory that launched Mia’s legal career and established the Squeaker Extraction Doctrine.

Case Won

Statement of Facts

  1. ¶ 1A stuffed duck was brought into the home as a "gift."
  2. ¶ 2The duck made a loud squeak whenever it was squeezed, bitten, or looked at funny.
  3. ¶ 3Mia decided that the squeaker was hiding something from her.

Arguments Presented

  1. ¶ 1Mia, representing herself, argued that she had a right to know what was making that noise.
  2. ¶ 2She argued that the squeaker was "hiding evidence" and "being a bit much."
  3. ¶ 3The duck chose to remain silent, which the Court took as an admission.

Holding

Judgment for the Plaintiff. Removing the squeaker was a proper and fair investigation. The stuffing is now evidence and has been spread across the whole living room for safekeeping.

“I simply asked the duck what it was hiding. The duck did not answer. So I found out.”
— Mia Filsinger, pro se

Have a similar case?

Sit. Stay. Consult.