Wu, Woof & AssociatesFree Consultation
← All Case Files

No. 26-MEOW-013 · Sunbeam District Court, Living Room Division

Mia Filsinger v. The Cat

A property dispute over the best sunbeam in the house, and a broader case about a Defendant who acts like she owns the place.

Case Won

Statement of Facts

  1. ¶ 1Every afternoon, a single perfect sunbeam lands on the living room rug.
  2. ¶ 2The Defendant, a cat, sits in it first every day, even though she has no job and could sit there any time.
  3. ¶ 3The Defendant also regularly walks on the kitchen counter, a place where dogs are not allowed, and looks down at everyone from there.

Arguments Presented

  1. ¶ 1Counsel argues the sunbeam is shared property and should go to whoever has been the best girl that day.
  2. ¶ 2Counsel presented Exhibit H, which shows the Defendant looking extremely smug.
  3. ¶ 3The Defendant offered no defense. She simply stared at the Court, blinked slowly, and knocked a pen off the bench.

Holding

For the Plaintiff. The sunbeam will be shared on a rotating basis. The Defendant was also held in contempt for knocking a pen off the bench.

“She thinks she is better than us. The Court now agrees that she is not.”
— Mia Filsinger, closing argument

Have a similar case?

Sit. Stay. Consult.