No. 23-WOOF-114 · Court of Front Door Appeals
In re: The Mailman
A First Amendment case confirming a dog’s right to announce, loudly and at length, that someone is at the door.
Closed
Statement of Facts
- ¶ 1A uniformed individual approaches the residence every single day and pushes paper through a hole in the door.
- ¶ 2Every single day, Plaintiff barks until he leaves. Every single day, he leaves.
- ¶ 3Plaintiff’s human filed a noise complaint, describing the barking as "unnecessary."
Arguments Presented
- ¶ 1Counsel argued the barking is clearly working, because the Mailman always leaves.
- ¶ 2Counsel cited the Doorbell Doctrine: any sound near the door must be answered with a bark of equal or greater volume.
- ¶ 3The defense had no response to the evidence of the slobbery envelope (Exhibit B).
Holding
Barking at the Mailman is protected speech. The Court also ordered the Mailman to keep coming back, so that justice may continue to be served, loudly, every day.
“He comes back every day. That is either courage or a cry for help.”