No. 26-SWIM-150 · Court of Aquatic Affairs, Backyard Division
Bessie v. The "No Dogs in the Pool" Sign
A Newfoundland, born to rescue swimmers, is told she cannot go in the pool. She calls it a violation of her basic job description.
Case Won
Statement of Facts
- ¶ 1Plaintiff, Bessie, is a Newfoundland, a breed known for water rescues and for being about the size of a small couch.
- ¶ 2The humans installed the Defendant, a sign reading "No Dogs in the Pool," at the start of summer (Exhibit T).
- ¶ 3Plaintiff has entered the pool anyway on nine occasions to "rescue" humans who were swimming on purpose.
Arguments Presented
- ¶ 1Counsel argued that the Plaintiff is not a dog in the pool. She is a lifeguard on duty.
- ¶ 2Counsel noted that every human the Plaintiff has rescued was, technically, brought safely back to shore.
- ¶ 3The defense raised concerns about the amount of fur in the filter. Counsel called this "the price of safety."
Holding
Judgment for the Plaintiff. The Defendant sign is removed. Plaintiff is named Head Lifeguard and may enter the pool whenever she feels someone needs saving, which is always.
“You do not tell a firefighter to stay away from fires.”